
Melrose River Club
Best for adults who want private spring-fed river access, a lively pool scene with cabanas and craft cocktails.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Melrose River Club is a 12-acre, adults-only boutique river retreat on the San Marcos River with private river access, a resort pool, cabanas and a seasonal pool bar. Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is a smaller, riverfront Gruene/New Braunfels hotel with a library, arcade and complimentary breakfast; read this if you’re choosing between a dedicated adults-only river club near San Marcos and a more established Gruene-area river hotel.
Updated · about 23 miles apart

Best for adults who want private spring-fed river access, a lively pool scene with cabanas and craft cocktails.

Best for travelers who want a quieter Gruene/New Braunfels base with easy access to Gruene Hall and complimentary breakfast.
When Melrose River Club wins: choose Melrose if you want a grown-up weekend focused on riverside swimming/floating directly from the property, a resort-style pool with rentable cabanas and on-site craft cocktails, or a boutique adults-only wedding or event.
When Gruene River Hotel & Retreat wins: pick Gruene River Hotel & Retreat if you want to be in or near Gruene (Gruene Hall is a minute away), prefer a hotel with standard front-desk services and complimentary buffet breakfast, or need modest conference/event facilities close to New Braunfels attractions.
Bottom line: Melrose is the pick for an adults-only river-club experience and poolside socializing on the San Marcos River; Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is a practical, riverfront Gruene-area hotel with breakfast and event space for guests wanting easy access to New Braunfels and Gruene.
| Category | Melrose River Club | Gruene River Hotel & Retreat |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique adults-only river club with a social pool/bar and event programming (Supper Club). | Quieter riverfront hotel tied to Gruene/New Braunfels with traditional hotel services. |
| Location | San Marcos — directly on the San Marcos River, about 10 minutes from downtown San Marcos/TSU. | New Braunfels (Gruene) — on Gruene Rd, minutes from Gruene Hall and Prince Solms Park. |
| Size & rooms | Roughly 42–43 cabins, casitas and a bungalow across 12 acres; room types include Classic Cabin, Deluxe Studio, Bungalow. | 17 individually decorated guestrooms across multiple named room types (e.g., NY Hideaway, The Vineyard, The Victorian). |
| Audience / age policy | Adults-only property — overnight guests must be 16+ (check-in agent generally 21+). | Adults-only per supplier listing (guests under 21 are not permitted); verify at booking. |
| Pools & waterside access | Resort-style 16×60 ft pool (guest-only) with rentable cabanas, poolside craft cocktails and private San Marcos River access. | No on-site pool published; property is riverfront on the Guadalupe River (short walk/drive to Gruene Hall). |
| Restaurants & bars | Pool & Bar — seasonal craft-cocktail pool bar; monthly Supper Club ticketed dining events; limited breakfast for surcharge. | No full-service signature restaurant listed; complimentary buffet breakfast served daily (8:30–9:30 AM). |
| Spa & wellness | Not published | |
| Event & meeting facilities | Numerous event spaces across the 12-acre site (Pool Courtyard, The Grove, Clubhouse, Pavilion) — small to large wedding capacities and BYO catering with in-house alcohol service. | Conference space ~650 sq ft (60 m²) and banquet hall; limited front-desk hours noted. |
| Parking & accessibility | Complimentary self parking, accessible path of travel and on-site wheelchair-accessible public washrooms. | Free self parking, elevator and some wheelchair-accessible features; front desk hours are limited. |
| Nearby attractions | Close to San Marcos river activities, tubing, Texas State University and San Marcos Premium Outlets. | Steps from Gruene Hall and within a few miles of Landa Park, Comal River and Schlitterbahn. |
Melrose River Club sits directly on the spring-fed San Marcos River, about a 10-minute drive from downtown San Marcos and Texas State University.
Melrose is for travelers who want direct San Marcos River access and a short drive to downtown San Marcos.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is a riverfront property in the Gruene area of New Braunfels, minutes from Gruene Hall and local riverside attractions.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is convenient for guests who want to be based in Gruene/New Braunfels for local music, parks and river attractions.
Melrose’s roughly 42–43 accommodations are cabin- and casita-style, many right on the river and designed for couples.
Expect boutique cabin or casita lodging with river views and in-room creature comforts tailored to adults.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat offers 17 individually decorated guestrooms with a variety of named room types.
Gruene provides traditional hotel rooms, each with its own décor and standard hotel amenities.
Melrose centers food and drink around a seasonal Pool & Bar and a monthly Supper Club series with rotating chefs.
Melrose focuses on poolside cocktails and curated, event-style dining rather than a full-service restaurant.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat offers a complimentary daily buffet breakfast plus casual on-site spaces and a library.
Gruene is the easier choice for travelers who want included breakfast and simple on-site dining options.
Melrose is built around its resort-style pool and private San Marcos River frontage.
If a social pool and river access from the same property matter most, Melrose is tailored to that.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is riverfront on the Guadalupe River but supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Gruene provides riverfront location and casual outdoor spaces; confirm pool availability before booking if needed.
Melrose programs low-key onsite activities and an adults-only social scene focused around the pool and river.
Melrose fits guests seeking relaxed, adults-only outdoor recreation and curated local-food events.
Gruene sits in a small entertainment district (Gruene Hall) and offers access to New Braunfels nightlife and live music.
Gruene is the better base for music and small-town nightlife with simple on-site entertainment options.

Melrose — private San Marcos River access directly from the property for swimming, floating and fly fishing.

Gruene River Hotel & Retreat — steps from Gruene Hall and the Guadalupe River, putting music and Gruene attractions within minutes.

Melrose — resort pool with seasonal Pool & Bar, rentable cabanas and ticketed Supper Club dinners.

Gruene River Hotel & Retreat — complimentary buffet breakfast and a 650 sq ft conference/banquet space for small meetings or events.
Melrose — it has a resort-style guest-only pool with rentable cabanas and a seasonal pool bar; Gruene’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Melrose is strictly adults-only (overnight guests must be 16+, check-in typically requires someone 21+). Supplier listing for Gruene indicates an adults-only policy (guests under 21 not permitted); confirm with the hotel at booking.
Gruene River Hotel & Retreat is right in the Gruene area, a minute’s drive from Gruene Hall; Melrose is about a 23-mile drive toward San Marcos.
Gruene includes a complimentary buffet breakfast daily; Melrose provides breakfast for a surcharge per OTA/site notes.
Explore how Melrose River Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·