
Melrose River Club
Best for adults who want a quiet riverside boutique stay with private river access and a resort-style pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Melrose River Club is a newly opened adults-only boutique river club in San Marcos with cabins, a resort pool and private access to the San Marcos River. The Faust is a small historic hotel on South Seguin Avenue in downtown New Braunfels for travelers who want a downtown base with familiar hotel services.
Updated · about 23 miles apart

Best for adults who want a quiet riverside boutique stay with private river access and a resort-style pool.

Best for travelers who want a downtown New Braunfels hotel with recognizable historic identity and 24-hour front desk services.
When Melrose River Club wins: choose Melrose if you want an adults-only escape directly on the San Marcos River, outdoor-focused amenities (pool, cabanas, firepits), and event-friendly grounds for weddings or gatherings.
When The Faust wins: pick The Faust if you need a downtown New Braunfels location, traditional hotel services (24-hour front desk, on-site bar/restaurant access), and proximity to downtown shops and museums.
Bottom line: Melrose is a purpose-built riverside boutique for adult getaways and small events; The Faust is a historic downtown hotel that works better as a conventional base for exploring New Braunfels.
| Category | Melrose River Club | The Faust |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Adults-only boutique river club with cabins, casitas, and a ranch-like 12-acre layout | Historic downtown hotel with standard guest rooms and hotel services |
| Location | 70 Riverbend Dr, San Marcos, directly on the San Marcos River (about 10 minutes from Texas State University) | 240 South Seguin Avenue, New Braunfels, in the downtown square area |
| Size (rooms) | Roughly 42–43 accommodations across cabins, casitas, and a bungalow | Not published |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only property (overnight guests must be 16+, check-in guest 21+; day pool passes 21+) | All-ages property (The Faust is not adults-only) |
| Pools & river/beach access | Resort-style 16×60 ft outdoor pool with rentable cabanas and direct private San Marcos River access | On-site pool: Not published; river/beach access: Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Pool & Bar craft-cocktail bar; Supper Club monthly dinner series; breakfast available for surcharge | Bar and restaurants listed on supplier amenities; happy hour available |
| Spa & wellness | No named on-site spa verified (spa references conflict across sources) | Not published |
| Known for | Direct private river access, adults-only atmosphere, event/wedding venues across 12 acres | Historic New Braunfels identity and downtown proximity to museums, shops, and the farmers market |
| Front desk / service hours | Limited front-desk hours (office/front desk staffing limited; check site for current times) | Front desk [24-hour] listed in supplier amenities |
| Parking | Complimentary on-site self-parking | Car park [on-site] and valet parking listed |
Melrose River Club sits on 12 riverside acres with three riverfront acres and direct private access to the San Marcos River.
Choose Melrose if you want a nature-forward stay centered on riverside outdoor activities.
The Faust is located on South Seguin Avenue in downtown New Braunfels, a short walk from shops, theaters, and the farmers market.
Choose The Faust if you want a downtown base for walking to New Braunfels attractions and dining.
Rooms at Melrose are cabins, container casitas, studios and a bungalow designed for adults and small groups.
Melrose’s rooms emphasize riverside, adult-oriented charm with small-kitchen conveniences.
The Faust offers conventional hotel room types and suites under familiar categories.
The Faust gives conventional hotel rooms and suites with some accessible options — good for travelers who prefer a standard hotel layout.
Melrose focuses on casual, seasonal dining and a craft cocktail pool bar with a monthly Supper Club series.
If seasonal poolside cocktails and chef-driven pop-up dinners appeal, Melrose is the stronger pick.
The Faust offers on-site bar/restaurant amenities listed among its services and nearby downtown dining.
The Faust works well if you want easy access to several downtown dining options and an on-property bar.
Melrose’s signature amenities are its resort-style pool with cabanas and direct San Marcos River access.
Melrose is a clear choice for guests prioritizing pool time plus convenient river access.
The Faust’s supplier listing does not publish a pool or river/beach access as a primary amenity.
If on-site pool or river access is essential, verify with The Faust — Melrose is oriented around those amenities.
Melrose keeps wellness and evening life low-key, focused on outdoor gatherings and occasional programming.
Melrose is for relaxed outdoor social time and curated events rather than late-night downtown nightlife.
The Faust’s downtown address places guests close to bars, live events and evening restaurants in New Braunfels.
Pick The Faust if you want to step out into downtown New Braunfels nightlife and dining after a day exploring.

Melrose River Club — private San Marcos River access, resort pool and an adults-only policy focused on grown-up downtime.

The Faust — downtown New Braunfels location within easy walking distance of theaters, markets and restaurants.

Melrose River Club — multiple dedicated event spaces across 12 acres and flexible indoor/outdoor wedding venues.

The Faust — traditional hotel amenities including a 24-hour front desk and conventional room/suite types.
Melrose River Club — it has direct private access to the spring-fed San Marcos River and on-site riverbank space for swimming and floating.
The Faust — it’s located on South Seguin Avenue in downtown New Braunfels within walking distance of shops, museums and restaurants.
Melrose River Club is adults-only (overnight guests must be 16+; pool day passes 21+). The Faust is not adults-only per the supplied facts.
The supplier listing for The Faust includes many amenities (bar, restaurants, Wi‑Fi) but does not publish a spa name or clear pool details; contact the hotel to confirm.
Explore how Melrose River Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·