
Melrose River Club
Best for adults who want direct river access, a social outdoor pool/bar scene, and a small boutique property that centers on outdoorsy, grown-up downtime.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Melrose River Club is a boutique, adults-only riverside retreat in San Marcos built around private access to the spring-fed San Marcos River. Homewood Suites is a three-star, Hilton-branded extended-stay hotel in New Braunfels aimed at travelers who want suite-style practicality and predictable brand amenities.
Updated · about 23 miles (≈37 km) apart

Best for adults who want direct river access, a social outdoor pool/bar scene, and a small boutique property that centers on outdoorsy, grown-up downtime.

Best for longer stays, predictable suite layouts with kitchens, and travelers who prefer a familiar chain with business amenities like a meeting room and fitness center.
When Melrose River Club wins: Choose Melrose if you want an adults-only, small-property river experience with private river access, a resort-style pool, on-site firepits and seasonal craft-cocktail service. It’s the better pick for couples, adult groups, or wedding weekends focused on outdoors and riverside time.
When Homewood Suites wins: Pick Homewood Suites when you need a larger property with suite kitchens, free breakfast, business-friendly services (meeting space, business center), reliable household-brand standards and easy freeway access in New Braunfels.
Bottom line: Melrose is a boutique adults-only river retreat built for outdoor socializing and events; Homewood Suites is a practical, family-friendly (all-ages) extended-stay hotel with suite conveniences and conference/fitness facilities. Your choice depends on whether waterfront adults-only character or extended-stay practicality matters more.
| Category | Melrose River Club | Homewood Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, adults-only riverside club with social outdoor spaces | Branded extended-stay hotel focused on practical suites and business travelers |
| Location | On the San Marcos River, 70 Riverbend Dr., about 10 minutes from downtown San Marcos and Texas State University | 620 Oxford Dr, New Braunfels; near New Braunfels Town Center and a drive from Gruene and Comal River |
| Size | Roughly 42–43 accommodations across 12 acres (12-acre, riverside property) | About 90 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / policy | Strict adults-only property — overnight guests must be at least 16; check-in age rules apply | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | One resort-style outdoor pool, 16-by-60 ft, private cabanas (rentable), pool bar; pool access for guests only and limited day passes (21+) | Outdoor pool (1) available to guests; wheelchair-accessible pool listed in supplier amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Pool & Bar craft-cocktail bar, seasonal hours; monthly Supper Club events and occasional breakfast for a surcharge | Bar/lounge on-site; complimentary continental breakfast (weekday times vary) and limited food service typical of Homewood Suites |
| Spa / wellness | Not published | |
| Known for | Private, direct access to the spring-fed San Marcos River and adults-only resort atmosphere | Suite-style rooms with full kitchens, free WiFi, free parking and reliable Hilton-brand services |
| Meeting & events | Multiple event spaces across the grounds for weddings and private events (indoor & outdoor options, up to ~150 outdoors) | Conference space ~603 sq ft (56 m²) and a meeting room; business center |
| Accessibility & parking | Complimentary self-parking; wheelchair-accessible path of travel and pool entry; single-level property, staffed limited hours | Free self-parking, elevator, wheelchair-accessible paths and parking; 24-hour front desk |
Melrose River Club sits directly on the San Marcos River and markets private river access and on-site trails.
Melrose is the choice for travelers prioritizing direct river access and an outdoor-focused stay.
Homewood Suites by Hilton New Braunfels is located in New Braunfels near shopping and highway access.
Homewood is practical when you want a recognizable brand base near New Braunfels services and attractions.
Melrose offers a small collection of cabins, container casitas, and a bungalow with boutique touches.
Rooms prioritize atmosphere, river proximity, and grown-up comfort rather than standardized chain layouts.
Homewood Suites offers studio and one-bedroom suites with full kitchen facilities for longer stays.
Homewood Suites is better if you need suite kitchens and consistent extended-stay conveniences.
Melrose centers dining around the pool bar, seasonal Supper Club dinners, and occasional surcharge breakfasts.
Melrose focuses on curated, social dining experiences and a seasonal cocktail program rather than all-day dining.
Homewood Suites provides complimentary continental breakfast and a bar/lounge for evening drinks.
Homewood is practical for mornings with included breakfast and nights with simple bar service and in-room cooking.
Melrose's signature amenity is its resort-style pool tied to the river experience and poolside bar.
The pool at Melrose is a social, adults-only focal point integrated with river access and events.
Homewood Suites lists an outdoor pool among its recreational amenities.
Homewood provides a conventional hotel pool as part of varied, family-friendly amenities.
Melrose favors low-key, outdoor socializing — firepits, Supper Club, and poolside cocktails.
Expect grown-up, outdoor-focused social hours rather than late-night clubbing or a full-service spa listed.
Homewood lists a 24-hour fitness facility and late services typical of a business-oriented chain hotel.
Homewood suits guests who want predictable fitness and front-desk services rather than an adults-only social program.

Melrose River Club — private San Marcos River access, riverside seating and a resort-style pool with pool bar and cabanas.

Homewood Suites — suite-style rooms with kitchens make longer visits and self-catering easier.

Melrose River Club — multiple indoor/outdoor event spaces across 12 acres for weddings and private events.

Homewood Suites — meeting room, business center, free breakfast and 24-hour front desk create a dependable option for business travelers.
Melrose River Club is adults-only (overnight guests must be 16+; day pool passes 21+). Homewood Suites welcomes guests of all ages.
Homewood Suites offers studio and one-bedroom suites with full kitchens. Melrose units may include kitchenettes in some cabins/casitas.
You can access and swim in the San Marcos River directly from Melrose River Club. Homewood Suites does not offer private river access.
Homewood Suites is designed for extended stays with suite kitchens, free breakfast and business services; Melrose is smaller and built around a short adults-only getaway or event.
Explore how Melrose River Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·